All or Nothing Review

REVIEW

✦

REVIEW ✦

All or Nothing, a one-shot BL manga by Shikke, offers readers a fascinating look into the evolving dynamics between two friends, Oka and Sawada, as they navigate their feelings and growing awareness of each other. So, is this one worth checking out?

Plot

The story begins with a revelation from their friends, Kadoi and Hasumoto, who have been secretly dating for a month. This news sparks a sense of juvenile jealousy in Oka and Sawada, not because they envy their friends' relationship, but because it makes them aware of their own lack of romantic connections.

This newfound consciousness leads them to become more attuned to each other, causing them to wonder what it would be like to explore a deeper relationship with one another. As they delve into these thoughts, they begin to develop a more profound awareness of each other's presence, setting the stage for an intriguing blend of drama and intimacy.

Characters

Oka and Sawada are the central figures of this narrative, and their relationship forms the core of the story. As two characters who have similar personalities, their transitional phase creates a strong (believable) dynamic and almost effortless relationship, filled with moments of awkward forwardness and conversely, dry reluctance.

The progression of their interactions, from casual friends to something more intimate, is portrayed with a sense of realism and relatability as they carefully introduce these changes to essentially test the water. Supporting characters like Kadoi and Hasumoto play crucial roles as a catalyst for the main characters' journey of self-discovery and exploration — opening their eyes to something that was there all along.

Art

Shikke's artwork in All or Nothing is visually appealing and masterfully depicts a romantic transitional phase as well as the bright personalities of these characters. The character designs and panel pacing expands the potential for storytelling, making the interactions between Oka and Sawada feel more impactful.

With each page, the manga’s art realistically portrays these exploratory nuances, making the emotional moments more poignant and the humorous moments more discernable. The moments of intimacy are also depicted with sensitivity and care, working within the general parameters of a classic BL story.

Themes and Symbolism

The themes of awareness, identity, and the complexities of relationships are recurring traits within the short story All or Nothing. The manga boldy explores how Oka and Sawada's friendship evolves into something more profound, highlighting the fluid nature of relationships and the importance of self-discovery.

The story also briefly touches on the theme of jealousy and how it can act as a spark for personal growth and change. The concept of "all or nothing" symbolizes the characters' willingness to fully explore their feelings without reservation — becoming a strikingly accurate title for the one-shot.

Verdict

Fans of the BL genre will appreciate the dynamic between Oka and Sawada, as well as the emotional and humorous moments that arise from their interactions.